WWE 2K’s MyRise mode has become a staple for fans who enjoy creating their own wrestling legacy. Throughout the years, the mode has delivered jaw-dropping storylines, dramatic betrayals, and surprising twists that keep players on the edge of their seats. Whether it’s an unforeseen heel turn, a surprise return, or a career-altering choice, WWE 2K’s MyRise mode has always packed in unexpected moments. Let’s take a look at some of the most surprising MyRise twists in WWE 2K history.
1. Betrayed by Your Own Tag Team Partner (WWE 2K23)
One of the most surprising moments in WWE 2K23’s MyRise mode comes when your closest ally turns on you at the worst possible moment. Just as you and your tag team partner seem to be on the cusp of winning the coveted WWE Tag Team Championships, they betray you, costing you the match and leaving your career in shambles.
This storyline twist is made even more impactful by the emotional investment players develop with their tag team partner. Whether you formed a dominant duo with a well-established WWE Superstar or an up-and-coming ally, the betrayal stings. It’s a true test of resilience, as you must fight your way back to the top, seek revenge, and reclaim your place in the spotlight. The sheer unpredictability of this moment makes it one of the most unforgettable twists in MyRise history
WWE 2K MyRise (Image via 2K Sports)2. Forced to Join a Rival Faction (WWE 2K22)
In WWE 2K22, players were stunned when their character was backed into a corner and forced to join a faction they had spent months feuding against. The storyline takes a dark turn when the faction’s leader blackmails or manipulates the protagonist into switching sides.
This twist puts players in a unique position—do they sabotage the faction from within, or do they embrace their new role and climb the ranks in this unexpected alliance? The branching story paths allow for multiple outcomes, making this one of the most engaging twists in MyRise history. The emotional turmoil of aligning with long-time enemies adds an extra layer of drama and player immersion.
3. Your Mentor Was Using You All Along (WWE 2K20)
One of the most heartbreaking twists in MyRise mode occurred in WWE 2K20, where your trusted mentor reveals that they were only guiding you to further their own career. Throughout the journey, this veteran superstar seemingly provides valuable advice, supports you in critical matches, and even helps you earn championship opportunities. However, just when it seems like you’ve earned their respect, they turn on you in a surprising betrayal.
This moment resonates because it mirrors real-life wrestling betrayals, where friendships and mentorships crumble under the weight of personal ambition. The resulting feud is emotionally charged, making for one of the most compelling MyRise story arcs. Players must then decide whether to take the high road or exact revenge in a brutal rivalry from start to finish.
WWE 2K MyRise (Image via 2K Sports)4. The Surprising Retirement Match (WWE 2K19)
Perhaps one of the most unexpected moments in WWE 2K19’s MyRise mode was the forced retirement match. In this storyline, your character is unexpectedly placed in a high-stakes match where the loser must retire from WWE permanently. What makes this twist particularly brutal is that it comes at the height of your career, when everything seems to be going perfectly.
This moment leaves players stunned, as they are left scrambling to either find a loophole to return or start fresh in an alternative wrestling promotion. The emotions run high, and for many, the unpredictability of being pushed out of WWE at the peak of success is one of the most memorable moments in MyRise history.