Every year, WWE 2K games feature an extensive roster of superstars, from legendary Hall of Famers to up-and-coming talent. While some wrestlers receive high ratings and special treatment in gameplay, others remain criminally underrated despite their real-life potential and in-ring skills. These hidden gems can offer unique playstyles and exciting matches if given the chance.
Let’s highlight four of the most underrated WWE 2K superstars ever. These wrestlers may not have the highest ratings, but they can still shine in your Universe Mode or online battles. Let’s get on the list!
1. Cesaro
The Swiss Superman Deserved Better
Despite being one of the most talented in-ring performers, Cesaro (Claudio Castagnoli) has often been overlooked in WWE 2K games. His general rating rarely reflected his true abilities, which included unmatched strength, technical skills, and aerial versatility.
- Why He’s Underrated: His ratings have often been in the mid-80s, while less skilled superstars have ranked higher.
- Best Moves to Use: Uppercut combos, the Cesaro Swing, and the Sharpshooter.
- How to Make Him Shine: Utilize his power-based moves and technical reversals to dominate in matches.
2. Chad Gable
An Olympic-Caliber Superstar Stuck in the Shadows
Chad Gable is one of the most technically sound wrestlers in WWE, but he has consistently been underrated in the WWE 2K series. With an amateur wrestling background and exceptional agility, he should be a top-tier mid-carder, but his in-game ratings say otherwise.
- Why He’s Underrated: His technical prowess is not reflected in his ratings, usually hovering in the low 80s.
- Best Moves to Use: German suplexes, ankle lock, and rolling deadlift suplex.
- How to Make Him Shine: Use his speed and reversals to counter bigger opponents and dominate the midcard scene.
WWE 2K Shelton Benjamin (Image via 2K Sports)3. Shelton Benjamin
A Veteran with Skills Beyond His Ratings
Shelton Benjamin has been an incredible athlete for decades, yet WWE 2K games have never truly done him justice. His speed, agility, and versatility make him an exciting character to play, but his general rating has been lower than deserved.
- Why He’s Underrated: His high-flying and technical abilities often don’t translate into high ratings in the game.
- Best Moves to Use: T-Bone suplex, springboard attacks, and Paydirt finisher.
- How to Make Him Shine: Focus on aerial offense and chain wrestling to bring out his best attributes.
WWE 2K Liv Morgan (Image via 2K Sports)4. Liv Morgan
A Rising Star Undervalued in WWE 2K
Liv Morgan has proven herself as a resilient competitor with great in-ring psychology, yet her ratings in WWE 2K games have often been underwhelming. As one of the most improved women’s wrestlers in recent years, she deserves better representation in the game.
- Why She’s Underrated: Lower stats in durability and striking despite her real-life improvements.
- Best Moves to Use: Codebreaker, running hurricanrana, and submission maneuvers.
- How to Make Her Shine: Play to her speed and counterattacks to make her a formidable opponent.