WWE 2K James Ellsworth (Image via 2K Sports)
Matthew O’Dwyer·
Tips and Tutorials
··
Last updated:
·2 min read

The Worst Rated Superstars in WWE 2K History

The Lowest-Ranked Wrestlers Ever in WWE 2K Games

Last updated:

The WWE 2K series has consistently delivered a vast roster of superstars, allowing players to step into the shoes of their favorite wrestlers. However, not all superstars receive favorable ratings. While legends and top-tier competitors boast high general scores, some wrestlers end up with shockingly low ratings. Whether due to their booking, in-ring skills, or career trajectory, these wrestlers hold the unfortunate distinction of being the lowest-rated in WWE 2K history. Let’s take a look at four of the worst-rated superstars in WWE 2K history.

1. James Ellsworth – WWE 2K18 (General Rating: 64)

James Ellsworth’s time in WWE was defined by his underdog status. Despite his brief run, Ellsworth earned a spot in WWE 2K18, but his rating reflected his lack of in-ring credibility.

Why He Ranked So Low

  • Ellsworth was mostly used as a comedic character rather than a serious competitor.
  • He rarely won matches on his own and was often portrayed as a joke.
  • His limited moveset and lack of athleticism contributed to his low rating.

While Ellsworth may have been entertaining, his low rating made sense given his WWE run.

2. Curt Hawkins – WWE 2K19  (General Rating: 64)

Curt Hawkins was known for his historic losing streak, which WWE leaned into for storytelling purposes. His misfortunes extended into WWE 2K19, where he was given a dismal 64 general rating.

Why He Ranked So Low

  • At the time of WWE 2K19’s release, Hawkins had lost over 200 consecutive matches.
  • His character was built around losing, which significantly impacted his rating.
  • Despite being a solid wrestler, his gimmick limited his perceived in-ring ability.

Even though Hawkins eventually broke his losing streak, he remains one of the worst-rated superstars in WWE 2K history.

WWE 2K JEva Marie (Image via 2K Sports)

3. Eva Marie – WWE 2K17 (General Rating: 67)

Eva Marie’s WWE career was filled with controversy, largely due to her perceived lack of wrestling ability. In WWE 2K17, she was one of the lowest-rated female superstars.

Why She Ranked So Low

  • Eva Marie was widely criticized for her in-ring skills or lack thereof.
  • She had minimal televised matches and rarely showcased high-level wrestling ability.
  • WWE focused more on her character work and heel persona rather than her in-ring performance.
See also

Although Eva Marie had a strong presence in WWE’s entertainment aspect, her low rating in WWE 2K17 reflected her struggles in the ring.

WWE The Brooklyn Brawler (Image via 2K Sports)

4. The Brooklyn Brawler – WWE 2K16 (General Rating: 69)

The Brooklyn Brawler was one of WWE’s most famous enhancement talents, whose role was to make others look good. His inclusion in WWE 2K16 came with a predictably low rating.

Why He Ranked So Low

  • The Brooklyn Brawler was rarely booked to win matches in his WWE career.
  • His role as a jobber meant he was never portrayed as a legitimate threat.
  • Despite his longevity in WWE, his in-ring skills never stood out compared to top-tier talent.

While The Brooklyn Brawler holds a special place in wrestling history, his WWE 2K16 rating reflected his role as an enhancement talent.