WWE 2K’s creation suite has always been a haven for gamers who love to push boundaries, crafting custom superstars that range from realistic to outright bizarre. Every year, players flood the Community Creations hub with extraordinary characters, some of whom rival WWE’s official roster in popularity. From jaw-dropping designs to pop culture crossovers, WWE 2K custom superstars have become a phenomenon of their own. Let’s explore five of the most unique custom superstars ever created in WWE 2K history.
1. The Fiend – The Ultimate Evolution
Bray Wyatt’s ‘Fiend’ character was already one of WWE’s most terrifying personas, but custom creators in WWE 2K took it to a whole new level. Modders and designers expanded upon the horror theme, crafting alternate versions of The Fiend that included monstrous mutations, additional masks, and even supernatural elements like glowing eyes and flaming auras. These custom renditions make The Fiend look even more nightmarish, providing players with a version of the character that feels like an evolution beyond what WWE originally presented.
2. Goku (Dragon Ball Z Crossover)
Anime fans and wrestling enthusiasts often overlap, and no character exemplifies this fusion better than Goku from Dragon Ball Z. WWE 2K creators have meticulously designed custom versions of Goku, complete with his iconic orange gi, blue undershirt, and spiky Super Saiyan hair. Many versions also incorporate moves inspired by his fighting style, with high-flying attacks and powerful finishing moves resembling the Kamehameha wave. The level of detail in these custom superstars makes Goku a must-have for anime and wrestling crossover fans.

3. The Joker (Comic Book Villain Reimagined)
The Clown Prince of Crime has made his mark in WWE 2K, appearing in multiple iterations across different games. Some versions lean into the classic comic book look with bright purple suits and a sinister grin, while others take inspiration from Heath Ledger’s gritty portrayal in The Dark Knight. Certain creators have even given the Joker a wrestling persona, complete with eerie entrance animations and maniacal laughter. His chaotic personality makes him a perfect fit for the squared circle, giving players a truly unique villain to unleash.
4. Jason Voorhees (Horror Icon in the Ring)
The Friday the 13th slasher icon Jason Voorhees is another fan-favorite custom superstar in WWE 2K. His massive frame, iconic hockey mask, and lumbering yet powerful fighting style make him an imposing figure in the virtual wrestling world. Many creators have fine-tuned his look, adding bloodstained outfits and unique weapon-based entrances to enhance his horror appeal. His slow, methodical movement combined with devastating power moves makes him a terrifying force in the ring.

5. Pepsi Man (The Most Bizarre Entry)
For those who appreciate a little absurdity in their WWE 2K experience, Pepsi Man stands out as one of the strangest yet most beloved custom superstars. Originally a Japanese advertising mascot, Pepsi Man’s sleek, silver-bodied design and corporate branding make him an unexpected yet hilarious addition to the roster. Creators have perfected his look, giving him an over-the-top entrance and even a high-energy moveset that complements his zany nature. His presence in WWE 2K proves that the game’s creation suite can bring even the most unexpected characters to life.