Kenny Omega (Image via 2K Sports)

The Best Custom Superstars Based on Non-WWE Wrestlers in WWE 2K

Bringing Pro Wrestling’s Biggest Stars to the Virtual Ring

Last updated:

WWE 2K games offer some of the most extensive customization options in the sports gaming world. While the in-game roster is stacked with WWE’s finest, the Community Creations feature allows players to bring non-WWE wrestlers into the game. Whether it’s stars from AEW, NJPW, Impact Wrestling, or other indie promotions, dedicated fans and creators craft highly detailed custom superstars to enhance the experience.

If you’re looking to expand your WWE 2K universe with elite talent from outside the WWE system, here are five of the best custom superstars based on non-WWE wrestlers that you should download.

1. Kenny Omega – The Best Bout Machine

One of the most sought-after custom superstars in WWE 2K is Kenny Omega, the former AEW World Champion and NJPW legend. His high-flying, hard-hitting style makes him a fan-favorite in both real life and virtual arenas.

Why You Should Download Him:

  • Signature moves like the V-Trigger and One-Winged Angel are perfectly recreated.
  • His attire, mannerisms, and entrance closely resemble his real-life persona.
  • With high ratings in agility, striking, and stamina, he feels authentic in any match type.

Omega is a must-have for any wrestling fan wanting to pit WWE’s best against AEW’s top star.

2. Kazuchika Okada – The Rainmaker

Arguably the face of NJPW, Kazuchika Okada is a five-star match machine. Known for his classic bouts against the likes of Kenny Omega and Will Ospreay, Okada’s presence in WWE 2K makes for a thrilling addition to your universe mode.

Why You Should Download Him:

  • His Rainmaker Lariat is meticulously animated for devastating impact.
  • His entrance and gear replicate his NJPW appearances, adding authenticity.
  • As a main-event-caliber wrestler, he fits seamlessly into championship feuds.

With Okada in your game, you can create dream matches with stars like Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins.

WWE 2K Kazuchika Okada (Image via 2K Sports)

3. Will Ospreay – The Aerial Assassin

Will Ospreay, one of the best high-flyers in wrestling today, is a standout performer in NJPW and AEW. His mix of aerial assaults and technical prowess makes him an exciting superstar to play as in WWE 2K.

Why You Should Download Him:

  • His signature moves, including the OsCutter and Stormbreaker, are expertly recreated.
  • Multiple attire options reflecting his NJPW and AEW eras.
  • A well-balanced stats setup highlights his speed, agility, and striking ability.

If you love high-paced, high-risk action, Ospreay is a must-have addition.

4. Jay White – The Switchblade

A master of mind games and technical wrestling, Jay White made waves in NJPW and, later, AEW. His heel persona and aggressive in-ring style make him a perfect addition to WWE 2K’s roster.

Why You Should Download Him:

  • His entrance, including the Bullet Club and Switchblade Era aesthetics, is highly detailed.
  • Movies like Blade Runner are well-animated and deadly.
  • His attributes reflect his strong psychology and counter-wrestling skills.

White is perfect for those who love playing as a cunning, cerebral villain in Universe Mode.

WWE 2K Jay White (Image via 2K Sports)

5. MJF (Maxwell Jacob Friedman) – The Salt of the Earth

One of the best talkers and heels in modern wrestling, MJF brings a unique character dynamic to WWE 2K. His attitude and in-ring psychology make him a fun and authentic custom character.

Why You Should Download Him:

  • His character model often includes multiple outfits, including his iconic Burberry scarf.
  • Moves like the Heatseeker Piledriver and Salt of the Earth Armbar add realism.
  • His personality shines through with accurate taunts, mannerisms, and mic skills.

MJF is a must-have for players who enjoy cutting promos and playing the ultimate villain.