WWE 2K games have long been celebrated for their robust creation suite, allowing players to design and share custom superstars. While the official roster is packed with WWE legends and current stars, the game’s passionate community ensures that fans can play as their favorite wrestlers from AEW, NJPW, Impact Wrestling, and the independent circuit. With highly detailed custom creations, players can experience dream matches and simulate inter-promotional rivalries. Here, we explore the best custom superstars based on non-WWE wrestlers in WWE 2K.
1. Kenny Omega
“The Best Bout Machine” Recreated in Stunning Detail
Kenny Omega, one of the most renowned wrestlers outside WWE, is a must-have in WWE 2K. Community creators have meticulously crafted versions of Omega, complete with his signature look, entrance, and devastating moveset, including the V-Trigger and One-Winged Angel. The attention to detail in these creations makes it feel as if Omega is part of the official roster, allowing fans to pit him against WWE’s top superstars.
2. Will Ospreay
High-Flying Action with the Aerial Assassin
Will Ospreay, a standout in NJPW and AEW, is another highly sought-after custom superstar. His fast-paced, high-flying style is well-represented in various community creations, with move sets that include the Oscutter, Hidden Blade, and Storm Breaker. Many creators also ensure that his attires—from his NJPW days to his current AEW look—are accurately represented, making him a perfect addition for fans of dynamic in-ring action.
WWE 2K, Will Ospreay (Image via 2K Sports)3. Jay White
The Switchblade Slashes Through the Competition
Jay White, a former Bullet Club leader and a top-tier competitor in NJPW and AEW, is a fan-favorite custom creation in WWE 2K. With detailed character models featuring his signature jacket, knife-edge taunts, and brutal Blade Runner finisher, Jay White’s presence in the game feels authentic. His cocky yet methodical wrestling style translates well, giving players the opportunity to recreate his biggest matches.
4. MJF (Maxwell Jacob Friedman)
The Ultimate Heel in WWE 2K
MJF is one of the best talkers and heels in modern wrestling, and his custom superstars in WWE 2K reflect his persona perfectly. Many creators meticulously design his attires, including his signature scarf and Burberry-themed gear. His move set features his signature Heatseeker and Salt of the Earth armbar, while his taunts and personality make him one of the most entertaining non-WWE wrestlers to play as in the game.
WWE 2K, MJF (Maxwell Jacob Friedman) (Image via 2K Sports)5. Kazuchika Okada
The Rainmaker Makes It Rain in WWE 2K
No custom wrestler list is complete without Kazuchika Okada, one of the greatest NJPW champions of all time. The community’s dedication to recreating his appearance, mannerisms, and move set—including the iconic Rainmaker lariat—ensures that Okada stands out among fan-made superstars. His entrance, featuring the grand Rainmaker pose, makes him feel like a true main-event player in WWE 2K.
WWE 2K’s community creations feature some of the most realistic and accurate renditions of non-WWE wrestlers, bringing AEW, NJPW, and indie talent into the game. Whether you’re looking to book dream matches or relive classic rivalries, downloading these superstars enhances the experience. Thanks to the creativity and dedication of the WWE 2K community, fans can enjoy an ever-expanding roster that goes beyond WWE’s official lineup.