WWE 2K Universe Mode is a dream come true for wrestling fans who love storytelling and booking their own shows. Whether you’re recreating legendary rivalries or crafting fresh storylines, the right feud can uplift your experience. With an extensive roster and customization options, WWE 2K allows you to build long-term story arcs filled with dramatic twists, intense battles, and unforgettable moments.
But what are the best feuds to simulate? To ensure an immersive and entertaining experience, you need rivalries packed with history, personal animosity, or compelling character dynamics. From classic WWE legends to modern superstars, we’ve curated a list of the most exciting feuds to play out in Universe Mode. These matchups promise great promos, high-stakes matches, and dramatic storytelling that will keep you engaged for months.
1. Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes – The Battle for Supremacy
Roman Reigns has dominated WWE as the Tribal Chief, but Cody Rhodes is determined to “finish the story” and claim the top spot. This feud writes itself, as Rhodes seeks redemption after coming close to dethroning Reigns at WrestleMania. The contrast between Reigns’ arrogant dominance and Rhodes’ underdog journey makes for a compelling rivalry.
In Universe Mode, you can build this feud with dramatic betrayals, intense promos, and faction wars involving The Bloodline and Rhodes’ allies. Add stipulations like a Hell in a Cell or Last Man Standing match to make their final showdown unforgettable. With Cody’s resilience and Reigns’ unstoppable aura, this storyline delivers pure wrestling drama.
2. Seth Rollins vs. CM Punk – The Real-Life Tension
Seth Rollins and CM Punk’s real-life animosity makes this an exciting feud to simulate. Punk’s surprise return to WWE has reignited speculation about a future clash with Rollins, who has been vocal about his disdain for the Second City Saint. This real-world friction adds an authentic layer of tension to your Universe Mode.
The beauty of this rivalry lies in their promo battles—Punk’s rebellious persona versus Rollins’ passionate title defenses. Let the feud simmer with backstage attacks, controversial contract signings, and heated confrontations. The culmination? A brutal No Holds Barred match at WrestleMania. If you want a feud filled with intensity and realism, this one is a must-play.
Seth Rollins vs. CM Punk (Image via 2K Sports)3. The Undertaker vs. Bray Wyatt – A Battle of Supernatural Forces
What if The Undertaker came back for one last feud? His perfect opponent would be Bray Wyatt, whose eerie persona has often drawn comparisons to The Deadman. This storyline could revolve around mind games, supernatural segments, and haunting promos as Wyatt attempts to usurp Undertaker’s legendary status.
You can build this feud with cinematic elements like graveyard brawls, cryptic video messages, and eerie interruptions during matches. Create moments where Wyatt seemingly controls the lights and manipulates Undertaker’s past opponents to play psychological tricks. A Buried Alive or Casket Match would be the perfect finale. This feud is tailor-made for Universe Mode’s creative freedom.
The Undertaker vs. Bray Wyatt (Image via 2K Sports)4. Gunther vs. Brock Lesnar – A Hard-Hitting War
If you love brutal, hard-hitting rivalries, Gunther vs. Brock Lesnar is a dream feud. Gunther has established himself as a dominant force in WWE, but can he withstand The Beast Incarnate? This battle would be a clash of titans, filled with intense brawls and powerhouse moves.
Set up their rivalry with stare-downs, contract signings, and surprise ambushes. Imagine a storyline where Gunther refuses to back down, leading to a brutal, fight-club-style series of matches. Their encounters should be stiff, with no DQ stipulations and multiple brutal power bombs. A match at SummerSlam or Survivor Series could solidify Gunther as a top-tier star if he defeats Lesnar.