WWE 2K’s Universe Mode offers players the ultimate sandbox for storytelling, allowing them to craft dream matches, rivalries, and surprising moments. One of the most exciting elements in wrestling storytelling is the unexpected return of a beloved or legendary superstar. Whether it’s a Hall of Famer returning for one last run, a forgotten talent making a comeback, or a surprising debut from the past, these surprise returns can electrify your Universe Mode.
Booking a well-timed surprise return not only shakes up the roster but also reinvigorates feuds, creates compelling storylines, and provides unforgettable moments. If you’re looking to inject excitement into your WWE 2K Universe Mode, here are some of the most thrilling surprise returns you can book to create an immersive and unpredictable experience.
1. The Rock Returns to Challenge Roman Reigns
The long-anticipated showdown between The Rock and Roman Reigns has been teased in real-life WWE for years. Now, you can make it happen in WWE 2K Universe Mode with a surprising return. Imagine Roman Reigns standing tall after defeating a top-tier challenger when suddenly, The Rock’s music hits. The arena erupts as The Great One steps into the ring, confronting his cousin and setting up a battle for the true Head of the Table.
This return would create an instant marquee feud, giving your Universe Mode a major WrestleMania-worthy main event. Utilize cinematic cutscenes, intense promo segments, and interference-heavy matches to build anticipation. Whether The Rock wins or passes the torch, this storyline will add a blockbuster feel to your Universe Mode and keep fans on the edge of their seats.
2. CM Punk Makes a Surprising Comeback
CM Punk’s name always generates buzz, making his return one of the most exciting moments you can book in WWE 2K Universe Mode. Whether you want to recreate his real-life WWE comeback or craft an alternate storyline, his return should be unpredictable and game-changing.
Picture this: A major championship match is reaching its climax when the lights dim, and Punk’s iconic “Cult of Personality” theme blares through the speakers. He storms the ring, delivers a devastating GTS to the champion, and raises the title in defiance. This return instantly injects a rebellious, must-see narrative into your Universe Mode.
From reigniting feuds with Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns to facing fresh opponents like Cody Rhodes or LA Knight, Punk’s return will uplift the intensity and unpredictability of your WWE 2K universe.
WWE 2K CM Punk (Image via 2K Sports)3. John Cena’s One Last Run
John Cena’s legacy in WWE is undeniable, and his sporadic returns always generate massive fan reactions. Booking Cena’s “One Last Run” storyline in WWE 2K Universe Mode allows you to build a compelling farewell tour with emotional weight.
The perfect setup? Cena shockingly returns during a major PPV event, surprising a dominant heel champion who claims to have no worthy challengers. With the crowd roaring, Cena challenges for one last title run, aiming to capture his record-breaking 17th WWE Championship.
His return could also involve rivalries with younger talents like Austin Theory or Bron Breakker, ensuring fresh matchups and dynamic storytelling. Whether Cena wins gold or ultimately bows out with an emotional retirement match, this storyline provides incredible storytelling opportunities, nostalgia, and high-stakes drama.
4. The Undertaker Rises for One More Match
The Undertaker’s presence in WWE is legendary, and while he’s officially retired, Universe Mode allows players to bring back the Deadman for one more unforgettable moment. Whether you book him as the American Badass or his classic Phenom persona, his return should be nothing short of eerie and dramatic.
A perfect scenario? The lights flicker during a major match, the gong echoes, and the arena is bathed in darkness. When the lights return, The Undertaker is standing in the ring, staring down a dominant force like Gunther or Solo Sikoa. The mind games begin, leading to a dream match that blends nostalgia with new-age wrestling.
The Undertaker’s surprise return can be the catalyst for a supernatural-themed rivalry or a classic retirement match where he puts over the next generation. Either way, it’s a surefire way to create a legendary moment in your WWE 2K Universe Mode.