WWE 2K MyGM Mode is all about building the most powerful and entertaining roster. Drafting the right superstars first can set the tone for your brand’s success, ensuring high ratings, thrilling rivalries, and an engaged fanbase. Whether you’re aiming for technical mastery, powerhouse dominance, or charisma that electrifies the crowd, making the right picks can make or break your General Manager run. Here, we break down the best superstars to draft first in WWE 2K MyGM Mode, ensuring you maximize your roster’s potential and dominate the competition.
1. Roman Reigns – The Tribal Chief of Success
If you want dominance from the start, Roman Reigns is the ultimate first pick. As the longest-reigning Universal Champion in modern history, Reigns brings a combination of power, charisma, and in-ring ability that few can match. His high popularity ensures that he will draw massive ratings for your show, and his ability to generate top-tier rivalries makes him a must-have asset.
Reigns excels in both singles and tag team competitions, making him a versatile addition to your roster. His feuds with top superstars like Brock Lesnar, Seth Rollins, and Cody Rhodes can create instant classic matchups. Additionally, his heel persona adds an intriguing dynamic to storylines, making your booking decisions even more exciting.
2. Becky Lynch – The Man of the Women’s Division
Becky Lynch is the definition of a game-changer in WWE 2K MyGM Mode. As one of the most popular female superstars, her presence alone can uplift your women’s division to main-event status. With her strong promo skills and impressive in-ring performances, Lynch guarantees compelling rivalries and unforgettable moments.
Drafting Becky early ensures that you have a cornerstone for your women’s division, whether as a babyface or a heel. Her versatility allows for legendary feuds with the likes of Charlotte Flair, Rhea Ripley, and Bianca Belair. Additionally, her ability to carry the division makes her an essential pick for keeping fans engaged and ratings high throughout the season.
WWE 2K Becky Lynch (Image via 2K Sports)3. Seth Rollins – The Workhorse You Need
Seth “Freakin” Rollins is a superstar who can do it all—main events, mid-card classics, and unforgettable promos. His ability to work with any opponent makes him a crucial first-round draft pick. Whether you need a reliable babyface or a top-tier villain, Rollins fits perfectly into any storyline you create.
His rivalries with Roman Reigns, Cody Rhodes, and Drew McIntyre ensure marquee matchups, while his in-ring style keeps fans invested. Rollins also has high stamina in the game, meaning you can book him frequently without worrying about injuries or fatigue. His ability to perform in singles and tag team matches makes him one of the most valuable picks for any GM looking to establish dominance.
WWE 2K Seth Rollins (Image via 2K Sports)4. Brock Lesnar – The Ultimate Attraction
If you want a superstar who guarantees destruction and high ratings, Brock Lesnar is the perfect pick. As a powerhouse and former multi-time WWE Champion, Lesnar’s presence on your roster immediately elevates the intensity of your brand. His sheer dominance in the ring ensures squash matches, brutal rivalries, and high-impact entertainment.
Lesnar’s unique ability to generate hype for any matchup makes him an invaluable asset. Whether he’s feuding with Roman Reigns, Bobby Lashley, or GUNTHER, his matches feel like blockbuster events. Additionally, his part-time status can be strategically used to create major pay-per-view moments, making him an ideal pick for long-term booking success.