The Most Underrated Superstars for WWE 2K MyGM Mode

WWE 2K’s MyGM mode is all about strategy, roster management, and maximizing your brand’s potential. While top-tier superstars like Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins dominate the scene, some of the most valuable picks are the underrated talents that fly under the radar. These hidden gems provide excellent performance, cost-effectiveness, and unexpected star power—perfect for budget-conscious GMs looking to create a well-rounded roster.

Let’s highlight four of the most underrated superstars in WWE 2K’s MyGM mode. These wrestlers may not be at the top of everyone’s draft list, but they can deliver exceptional matches, improve show ratings, and even outshine the big names with the right booking strategy. Let’s get into the best-underappreciated picks you should consider for your MyGM roster.

1. Chad Gable – The Technical Wizard

Chad Gable is one of WWE’s most technically gifted wrestlers, and in MyGM mode, his underrated status makes him a steal. With strong grappling skills and a versatile move set, Gable is a great mid-carder who can produce high-rated matches, especially in technical vs. high-flyer matchups.

• Pros: Great stamina, excellent work rate, and high technical stats.
• Cons: Lower popularity compared to main-event stars, requiring strategic booking to uplift him.
• Best Use: Pair Gable against agile wrestlers like Ricochet or high-profile names to enhance his credibility. Utilize rivalry-building and promo segments to increase his popularity.

By booking Gable in technical classics and capitalizing on his in-ring prowess, GMs can turn him into a fan favorite and a reliable asset for their brand.

2. Shayna Baszler – The Submission Specialist

Shayna Baszler is a dominant force with a ruthless submission-based style that can wreak havoc in MyGM mode. Despite her real-life booking struggles, she performs exceptionally well in simulated matches, often outperforming more popular female superstars.

• Pros: High durability, strong submission offense, and solid match ratings.
• Cons: Lacks mainstream appeal, meaning extra promo work is needed.
• Best Use: Position her as a dominant heel against high-popularity faces. Utilize her in stipulation matches like Submission or Extreme Rules to maximize her strengths.

Shayna’s ability to generate compelling feuds and deliver hard-hitting matches makes her an underrated yet highly effective pick for any GM.

3. Mustafa Ali – The High-Flying Underdog

Mustafa Ali may not be a household name, but in MyGM mode, his high-flying style makes him a must-have for engaging in high-quality matches. His agility, resilience, and ability to sell rivalries make him a fantastic mid-carder with breakout potential.

• Pros: Excellent agility, thrilling move set, and strong underdog appeal.
• Cons: Initial low popularity means extra marketing and rivalries are needed.
• Best Use: Book Ali against powerhouses like Gunther or solo stars like Finn Bálor to create David vs. Goliath stories. Use a ladder and TLC matches to showcase his strengths.

With the right push, Mustafa Ali can steal the show and boost general brand performance, making him one of the best sleeper picks in MyGM mode.

4. Bronson Reed – The Powerhouse Enforcer

Bronson Reed is a wrecking ball with immense power, but his lack of mainstream push makes him an overlooked gem in MyGM mode. His brute strength and devastating finishing moves ensure high-impact performances, making him an excellent addition to any roster.

• Pros: High durability, strong power-based move set, and excellent in big-man battles.
• Cons: Limited mainstream appeal, requiring careful rivalries and storyline-building.
• Best Use: Utilize Reed in feuds against smaller high-flyers or fellow big men like Sheamus to create classic powerhouse showdowns. Put him in title contention to build credibility.

With the right booking strategy, Bronson Reed can dominate MyGM mode and provide a strong presence in both mid-card and main-event scenes.