WWE 2K’s MyGM mode allows players to step into the shoes of a General Manager, controlling rosters, storylines, and championship reigns. While the standard experience is fun, custom scenarios can make it even more exciting. By setting specific challenges or unique stipulations, you can create fresh, dynamic gameplay that forces you to think outside the box. Whether you’re looking for a test of strategy, an unpredictable journey, or a completely new way to enjoy the mode, these creative MyGM scenarios will keep you hooked. Below are four of the most entertaining and challenging scenarios to try in WWE 2K’s MyGM mode. Each one offers a distinct gameplay experience that enhances the fun and unpredictability of running your own wrestling brand.
1. Legends-Only GM Mode
If you love nostalgia and the golden eras of wrestling, this scenario is perfect for you. In this challenge, your roster can only consist of WWE Legends. Superstars like The Rock, Stone Cold Steve Austin, and The Undertaker must headline your show, making it a battle of past icons. However, the difficulty lies in managing older superstars with high stamina costs and expensive contracts. Can you book compelling feuds without exhausting your roster too quickly? Additionally, rivalries must be historically accurate—no placing Hulk Hogan in a faction with modern-day superstars. The challenge adds layers of creativity, making you rethink your booking strategies while delivering classic wrestling moments.
2. Rookies vs. Veterans Feud
This scenario creates a compelling narrative by pitting newcomers against seasoned wrestlers. Your roster must be split evenly between up-and-coming stars like Bron Breakker and Carmelo Hayes and WWE veterans like Randy Orton and Seth Rollins. The main objective is to develop the younger talents into legitimate superstars by the end of the season. Can the rookies take over the brand and dethrone the veterans? Or will experience and ring psychology give the veterans the upper hand? Managing this delicate balance forces you to book matches wisely, ensuring your younger stars get the right momentum while maintaining your veterans’ credibility. It also adds a fresh twist to MyGM mode, making every rivalry and championship decision feel impactful.
WWE 2K MyGM Mode (Image via 2K Sports)3. Faction Warfare
If you enjoy stable rivalries and faction-driven storytelling, this MyGM scenario is an excellent choice. The rule is simple: your entire roster must be divided into factions, with no standalone superstars. Whether you revive classic factions like D-Generation X, nWo, and The Shield or create brand-new groups, every storyline revolves around faction dominance. The challenge here is to manage team chemistry and avoid repetitive match-ups while ensuring each faction gets its share of the spotlight. This mode thrives on long-term booking, as betrayal angles, leadership disputes, and faction supremacy battles will shape your entire season. With a structured approach to feuds and PPV matches, this scenario makes for an immersive, unpredictable experience where alliances constantly shift.
WWE 2K MyGM Mode (Image via 2K Sports)4. Underdog Takeover Challenge
In this unique scenario, you are only allowed to draft mid-card and lower-tier wrestlers—no main-event stars. The goal? Turn these underappreciated talents into bonafide headliners by the season’s end. Superstars like Chad Gable, Ricochet, and Xavier Woods must be booked into compelling feuds that gradually uplift their star power. The challenge is tougher than it seems, as ratings, ticket sales, and match quality all depend on how well you build these underdogs. This forces you to use strategic storytelling and smart booking decisions to create unforgettable moments. Watching an overlooked talent rise to the top makes for a deeply rewarding experience, and by the end of the season, you’ll feel like you’ve built a brand that values hard work over big names.